We Buy Your Cards.
SELL US YOUR CARDS!
We’re committed to providing the highest quality card selling experience to each and every customer.
We buy EVERYTHING, including bulk, vintage singles, and entire collections from Magic: the Gathering, Pokémon, One Piece, and more! We offer expedited service for lists presented at Market Low in the TCGPlayer App.
- Our offers start at 60% of the lowest TCGPlayer price for any card over $3 available from verified sellers.
- We offer 70% if you’d rather trade your cards in for store credit.
- We offer 50% of market value on all Sealed products, though we reserve the right to offer on a per-product basis for Pokémon and Magic of all eras.
- If you’d rather bring in your collection, we typically complete the process while you’re sitting with us! However, larger collections may take up to 48 hours.
- We offer payments through all major digital payment providers (PayPal, Venmo, CashApp, Zelle), cash in-store, and in-store credit to your personal account.
- All payments are sent within 12 hours of acceptance, though most are paid within minutes!
Ready to Sell?
Get the conversation started by emailing us at team@paradigmgames.co or bring your collection to the shop at 2479 N. Meridian Street, Indianapolis, IN 46208.
See our hours of operation below!
FAQ
Do you buy or sell One Piece?
We do buy One Piece singles. Please see above for details on the selling process. We don’t currently sell One Piece sealed products. We’re always evaluating our product offering and may offer this product in the future.
Do you buy or sell Yu-Gi-Oh?
We do not currently buy or sell Yu-Gi-Oh cards. We recommend seeing our friends at Grandmaster Games in Indianapolis, who are the local experts in Yu-Gi-Oh.
Can kids sell or trade Pokémon cards at Paradigm?
We love walking kids through the buying and trading process. They’re serious collectors!
Teens aged 13+ are welcome to trade cards with one another while at the store, but selling cards to one another is not permitted. For purchases of $50 or more youth must be age 15+.